IndiaCatalog.com
India News
Search Web Directory
News Home
Did Reliance Industries get away lightly in the unlawful gains case?
Posted on 27th March 2017
Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) on Friday delivered its verdict in the decade-old unlawful gains case involving the country’s second-biggest company, Reliance Industries. The capital market regulator has directed the Mukesh Ambani-led company to disgorge (give up) Rs 447 crore, with interest of 12 per cent per annum since November 2007, it made “illegally”.

Besides the high interest levied, the only punitive action is a one-year ban from dealing in the futures and options (F&O) segment by the company. So has the company gotten away lightly?

Governance firm InGovern’s Managing Director Shriram Subramanian says that the punitive action should have been stricter.

“Sebi needs to be more tough and proactive in such cases. It has taken almost 10 years to come out with this order, which doesn’t contain any penalty. This could set a wrong precedent for companies and market participants who brazenly violate regulations. Banning the company from the F&O segment will not have any impact on the company. Apart from the disgorgement amount, there has to be a penalty to serve as a deterrent to all market participants,” he said.

JN Gupta, former executive director, Sebi, and founder of proxy advisory firm SES, says that besides the company, those running the show should also be held responsible.

"This order reinforces the faith of investors in the market regulator that it will take to task anyone for the wrongdoing, regardless of the size of the entity. However, this once again raises age-old issues, such as whether the wrongdoing was committed by the company, which is a passive entity, or by the people managing the show. Obviously, a passive entity cannot commit any wrongdoing. Therefore, instead of penalising the company and its shareholders, action should be taken against the people who are responsible," he said.

According to the Sebi investigation, Reliance Industries, with the help of 12 front entities, took short positions in its erstwhile subsidiary Reliance Petroleum in the derivatives segment in November 2007. These positions were taken at a time when Reliance Industries was to divest five per cent stake in Reliance Petroleum. The divestment was carried out in such a way that Reliance Petroleum’s shares dropped in the cash and the F&O segment, the investigation showed. The 12 entities “made undue extraordinary profits on the open short positions”.

The profits made were transferred to Reliance Industries. They were accounted for as ‘other income’ in the profit and loss account for the financial year ended March 31, 2008, of the Mukesh Ambani-led company.

Prithvi Haldea, founder of Prime Database, says, "Disgorgement is a form of penalty. A disgorgement order indicates that the regulator has been able to establish that illicit gains were made. The real redemption in disgorgement is when you are able to identify the investors who lost their money and compensate them. If not, then use disgorged funds for investor awareness and protection programmes."

According to sources, Sebi had charged Reliance Industries with violation of insider trading rules in its first show cause notice (SCN) issued in April 2009. Later, Sebi issued another SCN in December 2010, superseding the earlier notices, in which the company was charged under violation of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practice regulations.

"Under Section 11 (B) proceedings, there is no scope of monetary penalty. The penalty can be imposed only after adjudication and by the adjudication officer which is not the case here. One should also not mistake the charges against the entities with the insider trading breaches. The action was taken for violating unfair trade practices regulation which is mostly for price manipulation,” says RS Loona, senior partner, DV Alliance.

The Reliance case dragged for nearly 10 year as there was a dispute between Sebi and the company for not providing it with some documents pertaining to the case. Reliance Industries had moved the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) over the issue. The tribunal in July 2014 had held Reliance Industries’ plea as not maintainable.

"Timely completion of investigations is one of the important yardstick for ensuring a fair, transparent and orderly functioning of the market. It is also vital for improving confidence in the integrity of the securities market. There have been instances in the past as well, where for example, Sebi has been pulled up by SAT for dragging cases for a long period of time or for inordinate delays in enquiry,” says Yogesh Chande, partner, Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas.

Reliance Industries is likely to move SAT against Sebi’s March 25 order. In a statement last week, Reliance Industries said, “Sebi appeared to have misconstrued the true nature of the transactions and imposed unjustifiable sanctions... We propose to prefer an appeal and challenge the order in the SAT.”

Related Companies: Reliance Industries Limited (RIL)   

Other Latest News
Bharti Airtel defers Q2 results till Nov 14 over ambiguity on AGR verdict
Posted on 29th October 2019

Bharti Airtel said on Tuesday it has postponed its second-quarter earnings report to mid-November, as the wireless operator sought clarity on the court ruling asking telecom firms to cough up overdue payments to the government.

Shares of the company, which was expected to release its quarterly numbers later in the day, dropped 3.3 per cent in early trade.


Rupee slips 8 paise vs US dollar in early trade amid drop in oil prices
Posted on 7th October 2019
The rupee on Monday opened eight paise lower at 70.96 against the US dollar amid drop in crude oil prices and rise in Asian equities. The domestic unit on Friday closed almost flat at 70.88 against after the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in a widely expected move cut key interest rates by 0.25 percentage point.

On a weekly basis, the local unit slumped by 32 paise.


LIC pips private insurers in first-year premium growth during April-August
Posted on 13th September 2019
In the first five months of the current financial year, first-year premiums of life insurance companies grew by 39.84% (year-on-year) at Rs 1.05 lakh crore as compared to Rs 75,588.35 crore in April-August of 2018-19.

Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) continued to grow at a faster pace compared to private insurance players, shows the data from the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (Irdai).


Apollo Hospitals rules out further stake sale
Posted on 13th September 2019
Apollo Hospitals Enterprise (AHEL) has ruled out further dilution of promoters’ stake in the company. The company also said its Rs 1,337-crore stake sale of Apollo Munich Health Insurance with mortgage major HDFC will be concluded by October. Following these stake sales, the promoters’ pledged position will come down from a high of 76% to 54% by October and eventually to 20% by November or December, company sources said here.

World trusts India on Kashmir, not us: Pakistan minister Ijaz Ahmed Shah
Posted on 13th September 2019
In a major embarrassment for Pakistan and its Prime Minister Imran Khan, the country's Interior Minister Ijaz Ahmed Shah, a retired brigadier, said the international community didn't believe Pakistan's narrative on Kashmir; instead it is India whose version is trusted.

» Post a FREE Classified Advertisement
Inviting Real Estate Agents, Job Placements Agents, Educational Institutes, Software Service Providers, Real Estate Builders, Marriage Bureaus, Travel Agents, Restaurant Owners, Health & Fitness Centers and other Local Businesses to Post a FREE Classified Advertisement on Cootera.com Classifieds Website.
Jobs in India India Real Estate Automobiles Matrimonials Beauty & Fitness

Add a comment for Did Reliance Industries get away lightly in the unlawful gains case?
Please only use this form to enter comments on the above company. All comments are reviewed before they are displayed on the web site. Not all comments may be displayed. Check back with us to see if your comments have been displayed.
If you want us to email the comments posted by users, please Subscribe by email
Name*
Comments*
Security Code*
 

Be the first person to write a business review for Did Reliance Industries get away lightly in the unlawful gains case?

Most Read News

More India News

  India Web Directory
Business Profiles
Yellow Pages
Photo Galleries
Global Web Directory
*** FREE India Classifieds
Order Premium Listings
Submit a Site
Business Reviews
Home
About us
Link to us
Advertise
Contact us
Google Search Keywords: India Catalog, IndiaCatalog, India Web Directory
    © 1999 - 2026 IndiaCatalog.com
    All Rights Reserved
Privacy Statement